Skip to main content

Guardians of Middle-Earth (Video Game Review)

Guardians of Middle-earth was revealed earlier this year and received a mixed reception likely due to the ever increasing popularity of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit franchises but also the reluctance of gamers to believe the Multiplayer Online Battle Arena genre that is so beloved by PC gamers could succeed on platforms. Obviously, the skeptics never played Awesomenauts on consoles when it released earlier this year, but where the Ronimo title succeeds on nearly every level, Guardians of Middle-earth stumbles out of the gate and has a few other flaws that keeps it from being a must play title. Leaning on the iconic book and film series will make Guardians of Middle-earth more popular than it should be, but MOBA fans can still enjoy, even on consoles.

Guardians of Middle-earth, like so many MOBA titles before it, doesn't feature much of a storyline. The greatest warriors of Middle-earth have assembled for the greatest battle of the Third Age. Troops will be deployed from either base and clash on the battlefield while the Guardians deal the majority of the killing blows in an attempt to overthrow the opposing army. Guardians of Middle-earth allows the most unlikely of combinations as heroes clash against one another and team up with former villains, and each character will be armed with customizable attacks, gems, relics and other equipment. Additional gear is unlocked after matches using currency earned in-game, and Guardians will automatically be strengthened through combat based on the equipped items. The system works similar to traditional MOBAs with a focus on crowd control attacks and area of effect attacks that makes the game focus more on the battles between armies than between the players. This design makes combat a bit cumbersome rather than unique, as players struggle to chase down and finish opponents before they escape and recuperate.


Even more troublesome is Guardians of Middle-earth's presentation that provides an overhead view that doesn't let the great character design shine. The sound effects, score and voiceover are all expertly designed, so it's a shame that it sometimes become difficult to follow the action of the game. Still, the most glaring flaw of the game comes in online matches where it takes far too long to find a match, and player drops are common no matter which team is winning at the time. Of course, you may not even notice the disconnects, since the combination of small text and zoomed out action makes it difficult to keep track of the entire HUD at one time. The one thing Guardians of Middle-earth does great that others do not is in the balance between characters despite the game featuring a large roster of Guardians to take into the 10-player matches. The game also gives the option of joining shorter, 20-minute matches or the full-length games.

Hopefully, the majority of Guardians of Middle-earth's problems can be fixed with a future patch, but as it stands, the game is a very average game with a big name and some major hindrances. If you're a huge fan of the Tolkien works, you'll definitely want to check this one out, but if you enjoy MOBA titles, you'd be better served picking up Awesomenauts on consoles or League of Legends if you don't mind playing on PC. Guardians of Middle-earth is an ok game, but there are plenty of other titles in the genre that are more worthy of your time.

Guardians of Middle-earth is now available for PlayStation Network and Xbox LIVE Arcade and can be purchased for $14.99 or 1,200 Microsoft Points. Guardians of Middle-earth is rated T by the ESRB for Fantasy Violence. For more information on the game, check out the official Guardians of Middle-earth website.

Game Features:
  • Online Multiplayer 1-10
  • Music and Characters from Popular Series
  • Online Leaderboards
  • DLC Support
  • Trophy/Achievement Support


    • Game Information:
    Developer: Monolith
    Publisher: Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment
    Platforms: PlayStation Network (reviewed) & Xbox LIVE Arcade
    Release Date: December 5, 2012

    Score: 6 out of 10

    Popular posts from this blog

    Crazy Kung Fu: A chunky, focused fitness‑meets‑reflex fighter (VR Game Review)

    Crazy Kung Fu transforms martial‑arts training into a physical rhythm game that sharpens reflexes and raises your heart rate: fast, reflex‑driven, calorie‑burning gameplay wrapped in deep moddability. What started as a focused VR reflex trainer has evolved into a vibrant, community‑shaped practice arena; richer environments, meaningful cosmetic rewards, and new systems that push precision, stamina, and skill growth in equal measure. What the game is • High‑intensity reflex combat : Fast, physical gameplay that maps your hands and body to punching, dodging, and blocking; scoring rewards precise timing and optimal range so every movement matters. • Deep, varied content : 72 handcrafted levels across four distinct modes (Train, Fight, Focus/Compete, Workout/Event), with modifiers and multi‑tier difficulties that scale from welcoming warmups to brutal, pro‑level tests. • Distinct, atmospheric arenas : Six immersive environments; from intimate dojos to a tranquil bamboo forest; each with b...
    Level Up: Read More »

    Captain Wayne: Vacation Desperation - Retro Rampage on Orca Isle (Game Review)

    Captain Wayne: Vacation Desperation detonates with hand‑drawn, ink‑drenched visuals and breakneck retro shooter action, grafting a double‑barreled shotgun onto a sailor’s arm and sending him on a gleefully gory rampage across Orca Isle. Released November 25, 2025 by Ciaran Games LLC and published by Silver Lining Interactive, the game fuses frantic boomer‑shooter gunplay with over‑the‑top animated cutscenes, a ripping, adrenaline‑driven soundtrack, and an endless arena mode that keeps the chaos replayable, equal parts cartoon carnage and twitch‑focused design that rewards speed, improvisation, and a taste for glorious destruction. Gameplay Loop and Systems Core loop • Shoot, survive, adapt : Move fast, read the room, and string momentum through aggressive play. Encounters reward mobility and timing; dash into cover, lay down suppressing fire, then finish with a brutal melee or explosive for maximum payoff. • Distinct weapon identities : Each tool feels purposeful; The Captain’s Ol’ Re...
    Level Up: Read More »

    Haymaker: VR Brawling, Up Close - Authentic, physics‑first combat that turns your body into the controller. (Game Review)

    Haymaker is a physics‑first VR brawler in active Early Access that prioritizes authentic, body‑driven melee and high replayability. Its core systems are already playable: weighty, physics‑based hand interactions for grabbing, grappling, and striking; gesture‑driven kicks and knees that reward full‑body motion; adaptive AI that reads and reacts to the battlefield; and sandbox encounters that encourage improvisation with props and environment. Many systems remain in prototype; levels, progression loops, and some modes are still being shaped, but the mechanical foundation is solid and satisfying. The studio is deliberately using Early Access as a development lab: player feedback will guide tuning, bug fixes, and content expansion, so the game you play now is a promising glimpse of a more polished, content‑rich brawler to come. Core systems and combat • Physics‑driven hands : Interactions are governed by a weight‑aware physics model that responds to force, angle, and momentum; so grabs, h...
    Level Up: Read More »